“Narratives of Anxiety” and Hidden Ontologies: Anti-vaccination Protest in “Conservative Orthodoxy” and Its Cultural Context

Protests against efforts toward coronavirus vaccination in 2020 and 2021 received significant support among Russian Orthodox “conservatives” or “fundamentalists” who consider vaccination to be a “chipping” that subordinates a person to hostile forces in preparation for the reign of the antichrist. The article examines the features of the conspiracy eschatology of modern Orthodox conservatives based on specific forms of ontology, aesthetics and social imagination. Abbot Roman Zagrebnev’s collected essays Deeds of Light and Deeds of Darkness (2016) and a number of other sources are used as empirical material for the analysis of these forms. The loss of a person’s individual agency as well as pollution, understood both in the moral and physiological sense, play a particular role in the social concept of conservative Orthodox. Each of these issues are discussed and represented with the help of bodily images and metaphors. The article attempts to see the meaning of conservative Orthodoxy not only through the prism of political ideals, social crises, and eschatological mythopoetics, but also through the connection of this particular type apocalyptic imagination of this kind and ideological holism as a crypto-ontology. The ‘holistic principle’ implies mutual conditionality and constant connection of physiological, moral and social categories and phenomena. This operates within concepts of an “expanded body” as an entity that is exposed to constant risks of pollution and loss of autonomy. In this context, the fear of vaccination, understood as both a form of physiological desecration and a means of social control, turns out to be a natural continuation of a broader ideological or ontological program that opposes the reductionist and discrete ideas about the world characteristic of late modern Western culture.

1. Agadjanian A. Soprotivlenie i pokornost’. Vyzovy pandemii, pozdnemodernye ehpistemy i russkii pravoslavnyi ehtos [Resistance and Submission. Pandemic, Late Modern Epistemes, and Russian Orthodox Ethos]. Gosudarstvo, religiia, tserkov’ v Rossii i za rubezhom [State, Religion and Church in Russia and Worldwide], 2021, no. 1(39), pp. 12–38.

2. Akhmetova M. V. Konets sveta v odnoi otdel’no vzyatoi strane [The End of the World in One Country], Moscow, OGI, RSUH, 2010.

3. Bessonov I. A. Kniga “Akh, mama-mamen’ka…”: Traditsionnye i sovremennye predstavleniya o kontse sveta [“Oh, mama, mama“ Book: Traditional and Contemporary Eschatological Notions]. Traditsionnaya kul’tura [Traditional Culture], 2011, no. 4 (44), pp. 140–148.

4. Clay J. E. Folklore and Conspiracy Theories of a COVID Dissenter: The Life and Sermons of Father Sergii (Romanov). Folklorica, 2020, vol. XXIV, pp. 135– 162.

5. D’yachkova N. Al’ternativnye mneniya o vaktsinatsii v religioznom diskurse [Alternative Opinions about Vaccination in Religious Discourse]. Quaestio Rossica, 2022, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 53–69.

6. Dubovka D. Sila slova startsa: mekhanizm osushchestvleniya kharizmaticheskoi vlasti [The Power of a Spiritual Elder’s Words: The Ways of Communication in a Community With Charismatic Authority]. Antropologicheskij forum [Anthropological Forum], 2017, no. 33, pp. 37–64.

7. Hegumen Roman (Zagrebnev). Dela sveta i dela t’my [Deeds of Light and Deeds of Darkness], n.p., 2016.

8. Hegumen Roman (Zagrebnev). Drevnerusskoe selo Zayan’e [Ancient Russian Village Zajanje], Pskov, 2005. URL: http://plussa-region.narod.ru/library/kniga_zayanje/kniga_zajanje.htm.

9. Knorre B. “Oprichnyi mistitsizm” v religioznykh praktikakh “tsarebozhnichestva” [The Oprichnina Mysticism in Religious Practices of Tserebozhnics]. Religioznye praktiki v sovremennoi Rossii [Religious Practices in Contemporary Russia] (eds K. Russele, A. Agadzhanyan), Moscow, Novoe izdatel’stvo, 2006, pp. 384–397.

10. Knorre B., Zasyad’ko A. Pravoslavnyi antiehkumenizm 2.0: mobilizatsionnaya model’, sek’yuritizatsiya i revanshizm [Orthodox Anti-Ecumenism 2.0: Mobilization Model, Securitization And Revanchism]. Gosudarstvo, religiya, tserkov’ v Rossii i za rubezhom [State, Religion and Church in Russia and Worldwide], 2021, no. 39(2), pp. 277–317.

11. Kormina Zh. V. Drozhzhi-ubiitsy: gastronomicheskaya konspirologiya i kul’tura nedoveriya v sovremennoi Rossii [Killer Yeast: The Gastronomic Conspiracy and Culture of Distrust in Contemporary Russia]. Antropologicheskii forum [Anthropological Forum], 2015, no. 27, pp. 142–175.

12. Luchenko X. Tsifrovizatsiya bogosluzhebnykh praktik v period pandemii koronavirusa v kontekste mediatizatsii pravoslaviya [The Digitalization of Worship Practices during the Coronavirus Pandemic in the Context of the Mediatization of Orthodoxy]. Gosudarstvo, religiya, tserkov’ v Rossii i za rubezhom [State, Religion and Church in Russia and Worldwide], 2021, no. 1(39), pp. 39–57.

13. Makarkin A. V. Russkaya pravoslavnaya tserkov’ i pandemiya COVID-19 [Russian Orthodox Church and COVID-19 Pandemic]. Neprikosnovennyi zapas [Reserve Funds], 2021, no. 4 (138), pp. 157–168.

14. Mitrofanova A. V. The Impact of Covid-19 on Orthodox Groups and Believers in Russia. Religious Fundamentalism in the Age of Pandemic (ed. N. Käsehage), Bielefeld, Transcript Verlag, 2021. P. 47–80.

15. Panchenko A. A. “Plan Dallesa”: sovetskaya literatura, teorii zagovora i moral’nye paniki v Rossii rubezha XX i XXI vekov [“Dulles’ Plan”: Soviet Literature, Conspiracy Theories and Moral Panicking in Russia at the Turn of the 20– 21st Centuries]. Russkaya literatura [Russian Literature], 2018, no. 2, pp. 118– 136.

16. Panchenko A. The Beast Computer in Brussels: Religion, Conspiracy Theories, and Contemporary Legends in Post-Soviet Culture. Folklore, Tartu, 2017, vol. 69, pp. 69–90.

17. Radchenko D. Instagram-sobornost’: konstruirovanie sotsial’nosti vo vremya kovida [Instagram Catholicity: Constructing Sociality During Covid]. Neprikosnovennyi zapas [Reserve Funds], 2021, no. 6 (140), pp. 135–157.

18. Tarabukina A. V. Fol’klor i dukhovnaya kul’tura “tserkovnykh lyudei”: Opyt issledovaniya sovremennogo fol’klora [Folklore and Spiritual Culture of “Church People“: A Study of Modern Folklore], PhD diss., Saint Petersburg, Institute of Russian Literature at Russian Academy of Sciences, 2000.

19. Viveiros de Castro E. Kannibal’skie metafiziki. Rubezhi poststrukturnoi antropologii [Métaphysiques cannibales. Lignes d’anthropologie post-structurale], Moscow, Ad Marginem Press, 2017.

20. Vorob’eva T. Lishennogo sana ottsa Sergiya oshtrafovali za rasprostranenie feikov [Defrocked Priest Fr. Sergius Was Fined for Spreading Fake News]. Rossiiskaya gazeta [Russian Newspaper], July 7, 2020. URL: http://rg.ru/2020/07/07/reg-urfo/lishennogo-sana-otca-sergiia-oshtrafovali-za-rasprostranenie-fejkov.html.

21. Vyazovskii I. “Kak velika tvoya lyubov’, o, Bozhe, k padshemu sozdan’yu...” (O prikhode v pskovskoi glubinke i ego nastoyatele o. Romane) [“How Great is Your Love, Oh God, for a Fallen Creature...” (On Parish in the Pskov Countryside and Its Rector, Fr. Roman)]. Vera-Ehskom. Khristianskaya gazeta Severa Rossii [Vera-Eskom: Christian Orthodox Newspaper of the North of Russia], 2002, no. 2 (409). URL: http://rusvera.mrezha.ru/409/main.htm.

22. Zygmont A. I. Sovremennaya prikhramovaya sreda kak soobshchestvo v situatsii zhertvennogo krizisa [Contemporary Parish Milieu as the Community in the Situation of the Sacrificial Crisis]. Religiovedcheskie issledovaniya [Researches in Religious Studies], 2016, no. 1(13), pp. 151–189.